There is something fascinating about what films were favorites of great filmmakers — especially when some of the selections are a surprise. In the past week, two lists for two major directors — Stanley Kubrick and Spike Lee — were released in different forms.
The late, great Stanley K.’s cinephile tendencies were the subject of a wonderful article by Nick Wrigley for the British Film Institute. As Wrigley writes:
“I count myself among the many admirers of Kubrick’s films and his remarkable aptitude for problem solving in all areas of life. I would argue that the only remaining unexplored area of Stanley’s life in film is his relationship with, and love of, other people’s films. In his later life he chose not to talk publicly about such things, giving only a couple of interviews to large publications when each new film was ready – but through his associates, friends, and fellow filmmakers it’s now possible to piece together a revealing jigsaw. I wanted to try and pull together all the verified information I could locate and have it looked over by a wise, authoritative eye.”
That eye belongs to Kubrick’s brother-in-law, Jan Harlan, who is interviewed by Wrigley in a separate story (see quotes below).
Wrigley points to a list Kubrick submitted to an American magazine named Cinema in 1963:
1. “I Vitelloni” (Fellini, 1953)
2. “Wild Strawberries” (Bergman, 1957)
3. “Citizen Kane” (Welles, 1941)
4. “The Treasure of the Sierra Madre” (Huston, 1948)
5. “City Lights (Chaplin, 1931)
6. “Henry V” (Olivier, 1944)
7. “La notte” (Antonioni, 1961)
8. “The Bank Dick” (Fields, 1940)
9. “Roxie Hart” (Wellman, 1942)
10. “Hell’s Angels” (Hughes, 1930)
Later, Wrigley mentions a list “that appeared in September 1999 on the alt.movies.kubrick Usenet newsgroup courtesy of his daughter Katharina Kubrick-Hobbs, a list of films she “happen to know that he liked:
“‘Closely Observed Trains’ (Menzel, 1966)
‘An American Werewolf in London’ (Landis, 1981)
‘The Fireman’s Ball’ (Forman, 1967)
‘Metropolis’ (Lang, 1927)
‘The Spirit of the Beehive’ (Erice, 1973)
‘White Men Can’t Jump’ (Shelton, 1992)
‘La Belle et la Bête’ (Cocteau, 1946)
‘The Godfather’ (Coppola, 1972)
‘The Texas Chain Saw Massacre’ (Hooper, 1974)
‘Dog Day Afternoon’ (Lumet, 1975)
‘One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest’ (Forman, 1975)
‘Citizen Kane’ (Welles, 1941)
‘Abigail’s Party’ (Leigh, 1977)
‘The Silence of the Lambs’ (Demme, 1991)
and I know that he hated ‘The Wizard of Oz.’ Ha Ha!”
Harlan points to others, including George Sluizer’s “The Vanishing” (1988): “Kubrick watched it three times and told Sluizer that it was ‘the most horrifying film I’ve ever seen.’ Sluizer asked: ‘Even moreso than The Shining?’ Kubrick replied that he thought it was.” As Harlan adds, “‘The Vanishing’ was real — ‘The Shining’ was a ghost film — a huge difference.” And the list also includes … “White Men Can’t Jump,” which is just awesome.
Wrigley asked Harlan for his thoughts on the undeniably enjoyable yet certainly silly documentary “Room 237”; Harlan’s thoughts.:
“I think it’s the silliest film ever. A complete rip-off. To say that hotel employees on the last day before closing — waiting with luggage for transport — is a reference to the Holocaust, is an insult to both Stanley and the victims of this greatest crime in human history. So are all other references to 1942. To go to the length of making drawings to prove that the large interiors of the hotel could never fit into the smallish place we see from the outside is a joke. Any schoolboy can see that! It’s a ghost film! Nothing [in ‘Room 237’] makes any logical sense.
I did not take the documentary that seriously — I thoroughly enjoyed it, yet never found any of the theories convincing. (It says a lot about how we read and interpret movies, sometimes illogically.) But it is unsurprising that someone close to Kubrick would have that reaction.
The rest of this week’s round-up, including a killer list from Spike Lee:
- Spike’s “essentials” list features a few surprises.
- A new movie starring Matthew Broderick is shooting in Buffalo.
- I have not seen “The Wolverine” yet, and think I may wait, but I enjoyed this analysis of the film by comic author Chris Claremont.
- “Just One of the Guys” is seared into my memory thanks to years of HBO airings. The AV Club looks back.
- Woody Allen’s “Blue Jasmine” beat the per-screen average of his biggest hit, “Midnight in Paris,” over the weekend.
- Speaking of Woody, a very cool look at how his posters reflect his films.
- Is “The Lone Ranger” misunderstood? Jerry Bruckheimer thinks so, as he would.
- Katy Perry as Rachael in “Blade Runner 2”? Oddly, I can kind of see it.
- And Toronto International Film Festival announcements keep on coming — more on this soon.
Image from BFI article. Stanley Kubrick, photographed by Dmitri Kasterine in 1969 on the set of A Clockwork Orange. Credit: Dmitri Kasterine: www.kasterine.com